Angelo's Pizzeria

117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019 Order now
Hero image

Coal oven pizza for the NY area!

quotation

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Angelo's Pizzeria Reviews on Grubhub

Brenna

1 review
My order wasnt just on time, it got to me earlier than the time frame given. The pizza was great and I would definitely order again!

Jeremy

1 review
Food arrived ahead of time right to my hotel door. Very tasty. Well packaged.

David

1 review
Its amazing and we will continue to eat there! Its great REAL food!

Will

1 review
Very friendly staff and the pizza was incredible

Oleg

Top Reviewer
Great Pizza! Everything was delicious.

Reviews from Seamless.com

Angelo's Pizzeria Reviews on Seamless

Alexandra

2 reviews
The best pizza that I have had in Manhattan. You can order from any of the locations, the food tastes the same, and excellent at that. I'm no connoisseur of the deep dish, New York style, etc...all I know is that Angelo's is cooked fresh in an oven, not greasy, and the pepperoni is highly recommended. The Caesar salad with grilled chicken is also excellent, but I'd pass on the tiramisu. Load up on the good stuff, the pizza and salad...and be sure to get a large, if there are any leftovers, it tastes just as good reheated the next day.

Richard

4 reviews
This is IMHO the best takeout pizza, and maybe the best pizza, in Manhattan. The crust is thin, perfect mix of chewy, crispy, and not-quite-burnt. Sauce and toppings are always fresh and top notch. I live down the block, so have never had an issue with quick delivery while the pie was still piping hot. Salads are good, not exceptional. Yes you can go to Brooklyn and maybe find even better, but this does the job consistently. It isn't cheap, though.

Betsy

Top Reviewer
Hands down my favorite pizza in NYC. Very thin, very fresh, best sauce anywhere. Only problem is you have to order far in advance if you want a lunchtime delivery because they seem to get backed up with midtown office orders. Worth the wait!

Kathleen

1 review
Consistantly good food. Pizza is wonderful - we always order pies to the office for group lunches. Dinner entries are a good portion and delicious. The Family size portions are great for sharing. Overall, would highly reccomend.

Mackenzie

Top Reviewer
Order was perfect. Delivery EST was spot on. Called prior to arrival. Food was still hot. fresh mozz cheese pizza .. Awesomeness!

About us

Dinner, Lunch Specials, Pizza
Today
Delivery: 11:30 AM - 9:30 PM
Takeout: 11:30 AM - 9:30 PM